After Night 3 of The Battles, Team Reba’s Manny Costello faced a stunning elimination, sparking an outpouring of concern and disappointment from fans across social media.
The country singer, who went head-to-head with teammate Leyton Robinson in a soulful duet of Chris Stapleton’s Think I’m In Love With You, had impressed all four coaches, with many praising the performance as one of the best of the season.
Ultimately, Reba McEntire chose Leyton Robinson as the winner, citing her desire to challenge Leyton with songs that would push her growth. Despite Michael Bublé nearly hitting his steal button, Manny was sent home, a decision that left viewers shocked and frustrated.
After days of silence, Costello broke his social media quiet with a heartfelt Instagram post that left fans even more emotional:
“What a WILD ride! So blessed to be a part of this show and forever grateful for the people it has put in my life. Praise God — through Him and Him alone is all this possible.
Congratulations to my partner @leytonrobinsonn — you crushed it! Can’t wait to see your next episode.
HUGE thanks to all of you who have supported me on my journey. I’m overwhelmed, to say the least.
This is just the beginning — we’re only getting started…”
The post immediately drew hundreds of comments from fans expressing both support and disappointment at not seeing more of Manny’s journey:
“You should have won! You’re so talented — the texture of your voice is so unique.”
“Wow. YOU 100% WON THAT.”
“One of those moments we watch the judges let the best singer just walk off the stage.”
“Can’t wait to watch you soar!! They really messed up on this one!”
“YOU ARE ONE OF A KIND!!!!! Only the beginning, friend!!!!”
Fans also praised Manny for giving credit to his faith, with one supporter commenting, “Very glad to see you give credit to God, man! So much love — God bless you and your family.” Others expressed hope for a possible return later in the competition, using hashtags like #BringMannyBack and #TeamManny.
Costello, a proud girl dad, has won admiration not only for his powerhouse vocals but also for his humble and faith-filled demeanor. His Instagram post reflects the optimism and gratitude that fans have come to associate with him, signaling that even though his time on The Voice may have ended earlier than expected, his career is only beginning.
As one fan summed it up perfectly:
“What a bittersweet feeling knowing you should’ve made it so much further, but also knowing this is only the beginning for you. Can’t wait to hear what you have in store for the future.”
Catch new episodes of The Voice on NBC at 8 p.m. ET each Monday and Tuesday to follow the journey of the remaining contestants.